On October 11, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, (USCIS), the American federal agency that oversees immigration, issued long-awaited guidance about the investment period (known as the “sustainment period”) required for EB-5, America’s residency by investment program.
The guidance stated that investors may receive back their required $800,000 capital after just two years from investing. While many in the EB-5 world have been waiting for USCIS to clarify the sustainment period requirement, the October 11 USCIS policy leaves open many questions, including whether the guidance itself was issued in accordance with proper procedures required under US law.
The official statute regarding EB-5 was updated with the passage of the “EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022” (the “RIA)” on March 15, 2022. As with the federal agency administering any official statute, USCIS must write formal regulations under a proscribed process. Only after a formal rulemaking process, which requires a public notice and comment process, do regulations become the rules under which the law is administered.
While EB-5 program participants have been asking USCIS to issue guidance and regulations, it is not clear that USCIS has the legal authority to change existing rules unless and until it follows the rule making process. This is especially true in cases where existing regulations can be read as consistent with the new statute, as in the case of the sustainment period.
The cause for this confusion is statutory language in the new law itself. The law requires that the would-be immigrant’s investment “is expected to remain invested for not less than 2 years.” The section of the EB-5 law regarding “removal of conditions”, or when the investor has a permanent green card, was edited to eliminate specific wording that the investor “sustain” the investment. The removal of conditions section, however, allows for an investor to have an extra year, beyond the initial two-year period of conditional residency, to prove job-creation only if they keep their capital invested.
It seems that USCIS interpreted these two provisions to require just two years of active investing. USCIS went further to require that the initial investment remain in the initial project until sufficient jobs have been created. However, the new law also provides for “redeployment” if an initial investment is repaid before an investor is qualified to be repaid.
A requirement to redeploy capital is illogical if the initial investment must satisfy the minimum sustainment period and job-creation requirements. The ability to withdraw capital after just two years seems illogical if the law allows an extra year to prove job-creation only if that capital remains invested for longer. When the RIA is read in its entirety, the new USCIS guidance does not seem to hold up.
The question of when the two-year investing timeline starts is also unanswered. The USCIS guidance indicates that the start date is when the full amount of the investment is “made available to the job-creating entity.” Is this when the EB-5 money is spent? When the loan is closed, but not yet funded? Can the EB-5 funds be deposited and not used by the job-creating entity? How does bridge financing affect this calculation? These are all unanswered questions.
In conclusion, EB-5 project sponsors must structure the EB-5 instrument responsibly, and EB-5 investors should not just rush into a deal that promises money back in two years. For now, it seems safest to maintain the EB-5 investment in the initial project for at least two years after the full amount of the EB-5 funds have been transferred to the JCE/borrower. Investors should stay informed of ongoing developments about the sustainment period, as this issue is sure to come up, again, in courts or USCIS policy in the future. More importantly, no matter what may or may not have changed in the rules, EB-5 investors must evaluate the financial and immigration risks of potential investments thoroughly.
To learn more about the EB-5 Visa program and Peachtree’s EB-5 offerings, contact agreene@peachtreegroup.com.
Many foreign investors have considered investing overseas to achieve portfolio diversification. Investing in US commercial real estate funds can be a particularly attractive option. In addition to shifting some assets to stable, US dollar-denominated assets, a portfolio of commercial real estate assets should provide less volatile returns than a single residential home or single asset commercial real estate transactions.
Investing in commercial real estate debt involves providing loans to property owners or developers. This strategy brings forth several key benefits:
The Appeal of Equity Investments involves owning a stake in the property itself. Here are the notable advantages of equity investments:
A savvy investor can further optimize their portfolio by diversifying across both debt and equity investments in commercial real estate. This hybrid approach balances stable income from debt investments with the potential for higher returns from equity investments. It is particularly appealing in times of economic uncertainty, providing a hedge against market volatility and multiple avenues for wealth generation.
Private equity real estate funds in the United States provide an opportunity for investors to diversify in two ways. First, by diversifying away from ordinary, publicly traded debt and equity securities, investors can earn returns that are uncorrelated to the broader stock market. Second, by investing in a fund with professional management, investors can earn returns that are less volatile than single asset investing while benefiting from the expertise and experience of the management team.
When looking to invest with a fund manager, consider the track record of the fund as a whole, and the experience of the individual executives on the team. In your due diligence, understand the investment process of the manager: how do they identify, underwrite, close, and administer individual transactions? Do they have a meaningful focus based on their experience? Have they established a successful track record?
Answering these questions will get you on the path to finding a reputable fund manager motivated to protect and grow your investment. It’s not easy to invest overseas, but with the right knowledge and partner, it can be a very rewarding experience.
About Peachtree Group
Peachtree Group is an investment firm driving growth with a diverse portfolio of commercial real estate assets and other ventures, with a specialty in hospitality. We’ve executed hundreds of investments since inception with a focus on real estate acquisition, development, and lending. Today, we manage billions in equity, augmented by services designed to protect, support, and grow your investment.
The EB-5 Immigrant Investor Program’s intent is to stimulate economic growth and job creation in the United States by attracting foreign investment into various regions within the United States that are in need of economic stimulus and job creation.
To be eligible for permanent residency via the EB-5 Program, a foreign investor must invest a minimum of $1,050,000. This minimum investment can be reduced to $800,000 should the foreign investor invest in a Targeted Employment Area (TEA).
In this article we will:
A TEA is a designation created by the U.S. Congress and enforced by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) to attract investment in areas that experience high unemployment rates or in rural areas. Therefore, there are two types of TEAs; Rural Areas and High Unemployment Areas. TEAs must have at least an unemployment rate of 150% of the national average.
The EB-5 Reform an Integrity Act of 2022 (RIA) brought forward visa set-aside categories or also known as reserved visas. There is a set aside of 32% of all EB-5 Visas. It created an annual set-aside of 10% of all the EB-5 visas for investments made in high-unemployment TEAs and an annual set-aside of 20% of all the EB-5 visas for investments made in rural TEAs. These set-asides offer post-RIA investors a potentially immediately available visa upon I-526Eapproval, even if they are from a backlogged country and offer an investment minimum of $800,000.
For an area to qualify as a high-unemployment TEA, an area must have an unemployment rate of at least 150% of the national U.S. average unemployment rate.
High-unemployment TEAs can now only include the census tract of the investment project and directly adjacent census tracts. This new definition was established by the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 (RIA). TEA designations are granted by The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. High-unemployment designation is valid for two years and can be renewed in two-year increments.
The set-asides offer post-RIA investors a potentially immediately available visa upon I-526E or I-526 approval, even if they are from a backlogged country.
A Rural TEA is an area that is outside of a metropolitan statistical area and beyond the outer boundary of a city or town with a population of 20,000 inhabitants or more. Rural TEAs encourage EB5 rural investment in rural areas that have a need for economic development and job creation.
Rural EB-5 petitioners are eligible for priority processing, although the exact timeline for processing is not yet defined by USCIS. The EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 established an annual set-aside of 20% of all EB-5 visas for investments made in rural TEAs. This set-aside offers post-RIA investors a potentially immediately available visa upon I-526Eapproval, even if they are from a backlogged country. Additionally, rural EB-5petitions may receive priority processing, which is an average of a 12-monthprocessing time.
A targeted employment area list can be found by using a TEA mapping tool. Invest in the USA (IIUSA), the EB-5 industry’s trade organization provides an interactive TEA mapping tool found here: https://iiusa.org/resources-data/targeted-employment-areas/. One can access the TEA map and review in-depth data about each census track. The map is updated annually with labor data released by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics by county.
The EB-5 investment amount in a Rural or High Unemployment Area TEA or Infrastructure project is reduced to $800,000 from $1,050,000 based on geographic and unemployment data issued by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
In addition to targeted employment areas, infrastructure projects also have a visa set-aside of 2% of the total EB-5 visas, and they are treated similarly to TEA EB5 projects in terms of the required investment amount.
The EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 defines between "targeted employment areas” and “infrastructure” projects; however, infrastructure projects are treated similarly to TEA projects as they have the same investment amount of $800,000 and also have a visa set-aside of 2% of the total EB-5 visas.
Peachtree Group projects are in Targeted Employment Areas. Current projects include:
Here’s how you can begin your journey to U.S. residency with an EB-5 investment, guided every step of the way by Peachtree Group's expertise and dedication to simplicity, transparency, and success. Learn more about The Peachtree Advantage.
Start by visiting our website where you can learn more about our specific EB-5 investment opportunities.
We designed our site to be user-friendly and simple.
Take a moment to fill out the contact form on our website.
When we’ve got your information, one of our investor relations managers will reach out to you.
Many foreign investors have considered investing overseas to achieve portfolio diversification. Investing in US commercial real estate funds can be a particularly attractive option. In addition to shifting some assets to stable, US dollar-denominated assets, a portfolio of commercial real estate assets should provide less volatile returns than a single residential home or single asset commercial real estate transactions.
Investing in commercial real estate debt involves providing loans to property owners or developers. This strategy brings forth several key benefits:
The Appeal of Equity Investments involves owning a stake in the property itself. Here are the notable advantages of equity investments:
A savvy investor can further optimize their portfolio by diversifying across both debt and equity investments in commercial real estate. This hybrid approach balances stable income from debt investments with the potential for higher returns from equity investments. It is particularly appealing in times of economic uncertainty, providing a hedge against market volatility and multiple avenues for wealth generation.
Private equity real estate funds in the United States provide an opportunity for investors to diversify in two ways. First, by diversifying away from ordinary, publicly traded debt and equity securities, investors can earn returns that are uncorrelated to the broader stock market. Second, by investing in a fund with professional management, investors can earn returns that are less volatile than single asset investing while benefiting from the expertise and experience of the management team.
When looking to invest with a fund manager, consider the track record of the fund as a whole, and the experience of the individual executives on the team. In your due diligence, understand the investment process of the manager: how do they identify, underwrite, close, and administer individual transactions? Do they have a meaningful focus based on their experience? Have they established a successful track record?
Answering these questions will get you on the path to finding a reputable fund manager motivated to protect and grow your investment. It’s not easy to invest overseas, but with the right knowledge and partner, it can be a very rewarding experience.
About Peachtree Group
Peachtree Group is an investment firm driving growth with a diverse portfolio of commercial real estate assets and other ventures, with a specialty in hospitality. We’ve executed hundreds of investments since inception with a focus on real estate acquisition, development, and lending. Today, we manage billions in equity, augmented by services designed to protect, support, and grow your investment.
